Table of Contents

Landscape Fabric or Plastic Under Rock: Choosing the Right Ground Cover

When planning a landscaping project involving decorative rocks, one of the first decisions you’ll face is what to put underneath. The two most common options are landscape fabric and plastic sheeting. Both aim to suppress weeds and stabilize the rock layer, but they function differently and offer distinct advantages and disadvantages. This article will delve into the pros and cons of using landscape fabric or plastic under rock, helping you make an informed decision for your specific needs.

Understanding Landscape Fabric

Landscape fabric, also known as weed barrier fabric, is a porous material designed to allow water and air to permeate while preventing weed growth. It’s typically made from woven or non-woven synthetic fibers, such as polypropylene or polyester. The porosity is key to its effectiveness and longevity.

Benefits of Landscape Fabric

Weed Suppression: Landscape fabric effectively blocks sunlight, preventing weed seeds from germinating. This significantly reduces the need for manual weeding and herbicide application.
Water Permeability: Unlike plastic, landscape fabric allows water to drain through to the soil, ensuring that plant roots receive adequate moisture. This is crucial for the health of any existing plants near your rock installation.
Soil Health: The fabric allows air to circulate, promoting healthy soil biology. This is beneficial for plant roots and the overall ecosystem within your garden.
Durability: High-quality landscape fabric can last for several years, providing long-term weed control. Its degradation rate is slower compared to plastic, especially under direct sunlight.
Erosion Control: Landscape fabric can help stabilize the soil, preventing erosion, especially on slopes.

Drawbacks of Landscape Fabric

Cost: Landscape fabric is generally more expensive than plastic sheeting.
Clogging: Over time, landscape fabric can become clogged with soil and debris, reducing its permeability and effectiveness. This requires occasional maintenance, such as sweeping or rinsing.
Breakdown: While durable, landscape fabric will eventually degrade, especially if exposed to direct sunlight or heavy foot traffic.
Weed Growth on Top: While preventing weeds from sprouting below, weeds can still grow on top of the fabric if organic matter accumulates.

Understanding Plastic Sheeting

Plastic sheeting, typically polyethylene film, provides a solid, impermeable barrier. It completely blocks sunlight, water, and air. While this can be effective for weed control in the short term, it also presents significant drawbacks for soil health and water management. When considering landscape fabric or plastic under rock, remember plastic represents the less breathable choice.

Benefits of Plastic Sheeting

Weed Suppression: Plastic sheeting provides excellent weed control by completely blocking sunlight and preventing weed seeds from germinating.
Cost: Plastic sheeting is generally less expensive than landscape fabric.
Moisture Retention: In some specific applications, such as creating a dry creek bed, plastic can help retain moisture in the surrounding soil if properly managed. However, this benefit is often outweighed by the negative impacts on drainage.

Drawbacks of Plastic Sheeting

Water Impermeability: Plastic sheeting prevents water from reaching the soil, which can harm existing plants and lead to water runoff issues. This is a major disadvantage in most landscaping applications.
Soil Degradation: The lack of air circulation under plastic can kill beneficial soil organisms and lead to soil compaction.
Root Rot: If water accumulates on top of the plastic, it can create a breeding ground for fungus and bacteria, leading to root rot in nearby plants.
Environmental Impact: Plastic sheeting is not biodegradable and can contribute to plastic pollution. It also breaks down under sunlight, becoming brittle and creating small plastic pieces.
Aesthetics: Plastic is not aesthetically pleasing. If it becomes exposed, it can detract from the overall look of your landscape.
Poor Drainage: Prevents proper water drainage, leading to potential waterlogging and plant death.

Landscape Fabric or Plastic Under Rock: Making the Right Choice

Choosing between landscape fabric or plastic under rock depends on your specific needs and priorities. Here’s a breakdown to help you decide:

When to Use Landscape Fabric

Gardens with Existing Plants: If you have existing plants near your rock installation, landscape fabric is the better choice because it allows water and air to reach the roots.
Areas with Good Drainage: Landscape fabric is ideal for areas with good drainage because it allows water to pass through, preventing waterlogging.
Long-Term Weed Control: If you’re looking for long-term weed control and are willing to invest in a higher-quality material, landscape fabric is the better option.
Slopes or Areas Prone to Erosion: Landscape fabric helps stabilize the soil and prevent erosion.

When to Use Plastic Sheeting (Use with Caution)

Creating a Dry Creek Bed (with modifications): If you’re creating a dry creek bed and want to prevent water from seeping into the ground, plastic sheeting can be used. However, it’s crucial to create drainage holes to prevent water from accumulating on top of the plastic.
Short-Term Weed Control (Temporary Solution): If you need a temporary weed control solution and are on a tight budget, plastic sheeting can be used. However, be aware of the potential drawbacks and plan to replace it with a more sustainable option later.

Important Note: Even when using plastic sheeting for a dry creek bed, consider using a layer of landscape fabric underneath to protect the soil and prevent weeds from growing up through any cracks in the plastic. The debate between landscape fabric or plastic under rock often ends with landscape fabric being the preferred choice for most applications.

Installation Tips

Installing Landscape Fabric

Prepare the Soil: Remove any existing weeds, rocks, and debris from the area. Level the soil and smooth it out.
Roll Out the Fabric: Unroll the landscape fabric over the area, overlapping the edges by at least 6 inches.
Secure the Fabric: Use landscape staples or pins to secure the fabric to the ground. Space the staples about 12 inches apart.
Cut Holes for Plants: If you have existing plants, cut holes in the fabric to allow them to grow.
Cover with Rock: Spread the decorative rock over the fabric, ensuring that it is evenly distributed.

Installing Plastic Sheeting (Use with Extreme Caution)

Prepare the Soil: Remove any existing weeds, rocks, and debris from the area. Level the soil and smooth it out.
Roll Out the Plastic: Unroll the plastic sheeting over the area, overlapping the edges by at least 12 inches.
Create Drainage Holes (Essential): Punch or drill drainage holes every few feet to allow water to escape.
Secure the Plastic: Use landscape staples or pins to secure the plastic to the ground. Space the staples about 12 inches apart.
Cover with Rock: Spread the decorative rock over the plastic, ensuring that it is evenly distributed.

Maintenance

Regardless of whether you choose landscape fabric or plastic under rock, regular maintenance is essential to ensure its effectiveness and longevity.

Maintaining Landscape Fabric

Remove Debris: Regularly remove any leaves, twigs, or other debris that accumulate on top of the fabric.
Control Weeds: If weeds start to grow on top of the fabric, remove them promptly. You can use a hoe or hand pull them.
Repair Tears: If the fabric tears, repair it with duct tape or replace the damaged section.
Replenish Rock: Over time, the rock layer may thin out. Replenish it as needed to maintain its aesthetic appeal and weed control effectiveness.

Maintaining Plastic Sheeting

Remove Debris: Regularly remove any leaves, twigs, or other debris that accumulate on top of the plastic.
Repair Tears: If the plastic tears, repair it with duct tape. However, keep in mind that plastic is prone to tearing and will likely need to be replaced more frequently than landscape fabric.
Ensure Drainage: Make sure that the drainage holes remain clear and unclogged.
Monitor for Degradation: Regularly inspect the plastic for signs of degradation, such as brittleness or cracking. Replace it as needed.

Conclusion

Choosing between landscape fabric or plastic under rock is a crucial decision that will impact the success and longevity of your landscaping project. While plastic sheeting may seem like a more affordable option initially, the long-term benefits of landscape fabric, including its water permeability, soil health benefits, and durability, make it the superior choice for most applications. Remember to carefully consider your specific needs and priorities before making a decision, and always prioritize sustainable and environmentally friendly landscaping practices. Ultimately, understanding the difference between landscape fabric or plastic under rock will lead to a healthier and more beautiful landscape. [See also: Choosing the Right Rocks for Your Garden] [See also: How to Install a Rock Garden] [See also: Weed Control Methods for Your Garden]